There are a number of reasons to love Halloween. For many, it’s a time to enjoy guilt-free, unrestricted quantities of candy and horror movies. For others, the joy of the holiday is hosting the yearly Halloween get together with friends. And yet for some, Halloween offers a chance to petrify people with their choice of creepy costume.
Finding the scariest Halloween costume for men can be a difficult yet enjoyable task for a number of reasons. There are, of course, several decisions that need to be made in order to arrive at the perfect scary Halloween costume for you.
1. Traditional vs. Contemporary Character
The first decision you need to make is about choosing a traditional favorite, like a mummy, werewolves, vampires and more. Alternatively, one might take on a contemporary character like Pennywise from It or Michael Myers to make the most of their current popularity. There are of course positives and negatives to both centering around how recognizable you want to be.
2. Solo vs. Group Costume
Secondly, you may choose to go as part of a group to your Halloween party or when you’re out and about. A group costume opens up avenues for more creative collaborations, but it can be tough to get everyone to agree. We’ve focused our selections on solo costumes, but there are plenty of great group costumes that will make everyone scream with fright.
Finally, there’s your budget to consider. With amazing makeup and professional-standard costumes, it can be difficult to stick to your financial guns if you’re on a budget. If you aren’t limited by the cash in your pocket, the sky’s the limit, and there are some truly spectacular scary costumes for sale.
Once you’ve decided on your answers to the above, keep reading.
We’ve put together 50 of our favorite scary costumes for men. This list includes options for all types of scares across both classic and contemporary choices. You’ll also find quick outfits for last-minute decisions as well as other costumes which can be added to with fake blood, wigs and other accessories for a more committed look.
Take a scroll through our favorites and find the outfit you think will score you the most scares this Halloween.
1. Morphsuits Urban Legends Creepypasta Costume
BEST CREEPYPASTA COSTUME
Being served undercooked ravioli is terrible, but this Morphsuits Urban Legends Costume is dealing with a whole different level of creepypasta. Each of these full-body suits is inspired by one of the many Creepypasta characters. From Eyeless Jack to Jack O Lantern, there’s a suit to suit everyone. The costumes are made from high-quality materials that allow for four-way stretching. They also include double zips and reinforced stitching to further ensure durability and quality.
2. Ghoulish Productions Infected Adult Mask
BEST ZOMBIE MASK
Nothing is more terrifying than a zombie with an appetite for human flesh, and this ravenous mask is absolutely savage. The bloody full-face mask — complete with lifeless black eyes, bulging veins, and a bloody mouth — looks like it was created by a Hollywood effects studio. It’ll have everyone running for the hills.
Image courtesy of Amazon
3. Leather Plague Doctor Mask
Whether you’re aware of the origins of this costume or not, it’s hard to deny that it gives off a truly creepy air. According to legend, this creepy bird-like mask was originally designed and worn by doctors tasked with treating the bubonic plague. And considering tha we all just survived a plague of our own, this Leather Plague Doctor Mask is sure to give people the creeps on All Hallows’ Eve. Is it in good taste? Maybe not. Is it a truly scary Halloween costume for 2021? There’s no doubt about it.
4. Morphsuit Mask
We know you know the Morphsuit look at this point. Creep up behind someone wearing this scary Halloween mask and you’re sure to give them a scare — you don’t even have to say “Boo!” While there aren’t many people sporting them during Halloween anymore, this blank white mask is an awesome and unsettling way to throw together a last-minute Halloween costume. You don’t have to do too much with this one, we suggest maybe thrifting an old-timey suit and briefcase and stay silent the whole night. We promise you’ll totally freak some people out.
5. Spirit Halloween Adult Haunting Scarecrow Costume
“What’s that in the cornfield?” Whatever it is, you’re surely not going to want to find out. This undead scarecrow costume comes with gear that will cover you from top to bottom. The set includes a two-in-one shirt, belt, gloves, mask, hat and pants, so you don’t have to worry about a thing.
6. Donald Trump Mask
The 45th President of the United States is perhaps the most divisive figure in the history of the world. For progressives, the mere sight of his orange countenance and blonde hair is enough to scare you. For conservatives, there’s nothing more satisfying than scaring liberals. So if you’re looking for a scary Halloween costume that’s 100% guaranteed to trigger people, this is it.
7. Adult Creepy Pasta Scary Halloween Mask
Don’t frown! This smiley creeper elevates any traditional mask to the next level. With a daunting, noseless happy face, darkened eyes a weird skinlike material all over the place, this mask will send shivers down anyone’s spine. Pair it with a dapper suit and you’ll have yourself a super scary Halloween costume for men this year.
Related: The Best Halloween Costumes
8. Adult Demon Reaper Costume
BEST DEMON COSTUME
Somebody call a priest because this costume might require an exorcism. The demonic look comes with a hooded reaper robe and a blood-splattered, pointy-eared mask that will have even the darkest creatures of the underworld growling.
Related: Best Halloween Costume Ideas For Men
9. Hugz The Clown Costume
Although you might see a scary clown costume one or two more times in this round-up, none have as sinister of an intention as Hugz the Clown. From the horrifying mask to the blood-splattered onesie topped off with a “Free Hugz!” sign dangling around the costume’s front, scare the hell out of local kids and neighbors this year with a look that will have them running for their lives.
10. Kvvdi Blank Face Mask
Could you imagine walking down the street and seeing someone wearing this? Even though it’s a very simple mask, it’s still downright creepy. The plain white mask comes with an elastic strap and a foam pad on the forehead to keep the emotionless face snug in place.
Related: Best Cheap Halloween Costumes
11. CreepyParty Releastic Baby Mask
Boohoo. A crying baby. But, this isn’t just any crying baby. Unlike the whines and cries you’d get from a real-life infant, this stuck crying baby mask is absolutely terrifying. It’s oversize to fit your adult head and will surely get both laughs and cowers from onlookers.
12. California Costumes Men’s Werewolf Costume
BEST WEREWOLF COSTUME
Halloween falls on a full moon this year, so if you’ve ever contemplated dressing as a werewolf, 2021 is the year to do it! Now it’s time for the beast to come out and play. Pair this mask, glove and shirt combo with some ripped jeans, practice your howls, and you’ll be good to go.
13. Costumeparty Momo Mask
You might remember the eerie Momo meme that has been circulating around the internet over the past few years. Well, now there is a mask so you can bring the creepy, bug-eyed face with a sinister grin to life. This is easily one of the scariest masks for men this year.
14. Annabelle Costume
Unless you’ve been living under a rock, you probably heard through some hilarious Twitter memes that the haunted doll Annabelle escaped from her encasing at the museum she was on display at the Warren Occult Museum in Connecticut last year. Though that was just a rumor, there were loads of knee-slapping memes that came from the thought of her runaway, with photos of her in a bikini in the Bahamas to a TikTok skit imagining Annebelle’s post-escape phone call with the devil. That being said, Annabelle will make an excellent costume this Halloween.
15. Leka Neil Old Man Mask
CREEPIEST OLD PERSON
This highly detailed old man mask will have you screaming “get off my lawn” at the neighborhood kids in no time. The creepy mask is made of a soft, non-toxic latex material that pays extra close attention to the details around the cheeks and nose — making it eerily realistic.
Image courtesy of Amazon
16. CASACLAUSI Jason Mask
BEST YEAR AFTER YEAR
You may not have realized it, but the original mask used in the 1980 Friday the 13th film was modeled from a Detroit Red Wings goalie mask. This visual would go on to become one of the most recognizable Halloween costumes over the years and remains that way, even today. In this CASACLAUSI Jason Mask, you’ll be able to become the face behind the mask and also have the choice of six different colors for your own personal spin.
17. XuanYou Upside Down Mask
MOST KOOKY COSTUME
If you want a quick and creepy answer to your Halloween costume this year, try this XuanYou Upside Down Mask. In your hands, it may appear just like any other weird mask, but it’s only when you put it on that you’ll realize the real beauty of the mask. The head is mounted upside down, meaning the eyes are down and the mouth is up. It’s very much a costume that creates severe discomfort in onlookers because they are witnessing something truly unnatural. Add in a few painful screams, and you’re definitely going to give kids (and adults) some sleepless nights.
18. Moonideal Halloween Light Up Mask
BEST LAST-MINUTE COSTUME
The Moonideal Halloween Light Up Mask is simple yet effective. It’s available in orange, purple, red or green and looks scary enough in the light with its cross-stitched eyes and mouth. However, when the lights go off, the mask really comes to life as the wire used for the eyes, mouth and outer lining is Electroluminescent (EL) Wire, delivering a haunting, in-your-face look that’s hard to miss. The mask can easily work by itself, or it can be combined with other costumes to boost the impression. This is a great choice for low-light events like discos, raves and evening events.
19. Adult Psycho Straitjacket
Make it look like you’ve just escaped the ward to celebrate Halloween this year with this straitjacket suited for all of the psycho things you’re going to get yourself into this year. Whether you’re headed to a Halloween party, giving candy to kids or roaming around town, you’re going to need a helping hand at some point. You know, since you won’t be able to use your hands at all.
20. Morphsuits Alien Chest Illusion Costume
BEST COSTUME FOR ACTORS
Picture the scene: everyone’s disappointed you decided not to partake in the costume competition this year. Then, after just enough time passes for people to be truly convinced, you run into the middle of the room, scream loudly and rip open your shirt to reveal an alien making its way through your rib cage (*bursting ketchup packets optional). All you need to pull off this costume is this illusion costume, a disposable button-up shirt and a low-level ability to act.
21. Xiao Chou Ri Ji Scary Latex Mask
MOST OBSCURE MOVIE REFERENCE
A pig-headed person is always going to leave a lasting impression. In the case of this Xiao Chou Ri Ji Scary Mask, you have a double whammy on your hands as the mask looks exactly like the one used in the original Saw film (minus the hair). As such, it brings back the fear the mask induced for people who have seen the film. It’s also hideous enough to scare someone who has no idea about the film reference either. This versatile option can be used with pretty much any outfit, making it a great last-minute option.
22. It Chapter Two Tattered Pennywise Costume
BEST IT COSTUME
No matter what year it is and whether or not there is a new It movie in the works, a Pennywise costume is a standout every Halloween. Like, come on. That dude is way too creepy. There are tons of Pennywise costumes to choose from online, but this one is taking the cake for us right now. Just looking at that face is giving us the shivers. This is a terrifyingly scary Halloween costume for men year after year.
23. H&ZY Halloween Hooded Cloak
There are few scarier things in the world than the unknown. And by putting this H&ZY Unisex Tunic Halloween Hooded Cloak over you, bystanders will have no idea what lies beneath. Such mystique gives the cloak lots of versatility for Halloween and other occasions, like masquerades and costume parties. It also means it can be worn with no other accessories, making it a great last-minute costume idea. Alternatively, it can be paired with an even scarier mask or face paint for a truly terrifying reveal.
24. Cafele Halloween Michael Myers Mask
MOST POPULAR COSTUME
Whether you see it or not, Michael Myers is scary. Eleven feature films (and counting) suggest that while people remain scared by his seemingly endless love for the murder of everyone he encounters, the public simply can’t get enough of this character. This Cafele Halloween Michael Myers Mask comes straight from the 2018 film and combines well with a set of his favorite overalls to give you an outfit to span the ages. Remember, Michael first appeared in 1978’s Halloween.
25. Rubie’s Scary The Nun Movie Deluxe Costume
BEST HORROR COSTUME
Did you know the nun from The Conjuring movie was so scary that they gave her her own movie called The Nun? You can channel that same horror with the Rubie’s Scary The Nun Movie Deluxe Costume, which is surprisingly affordable for a complete set. It comes with a full habit, a veil and a mask for a terrifying look. And even though nuns are traditionally women, this costume is officially unisex, and a tall or built man will certainly make the outfit look imposing and noticeable.
26. Twisty the Clown Costume
BEST FOR AHS FANS
Are you an American Horror Story buff? Then you’ll know damn well who this creepy clown is. Twisty is a murderous serial killing clown with a traumatic past that lead to his desire to kill. Below his mask is an even more heinous face, so the mask is solely used to cover up his true identity. Though this costume doesn’t come with a mask reveal similar to that scene in the series, you’ll look menacing as can be dressed as Twisty.
27. CreepyParty Deluxe Dog Head Mask
Sometimes scary doesn’t have to be complicated or clever. You just imagine something creepy and make it. Enter the CreepyParty Deluxe Dog Head Mask. Shockingly realistic, this mask can be paired with normal, human clothes for a confusingly creepy costume. Anatomically, the mask has the fur, snout and piercing eyes of a poodle. While this isn’t the type of mask normal nightmares are made of, it will surely inspire a few after you wear it to the Halloween party. Like we said, sometimes scary is simple.
28. Headless Horseman Costume
Rocking a look this scary is a no brainer. Literally. Proving that spooky doesn’t always have to include your face, this headless horseman costume is a shocking costume choice that will absolutely confuse the hell out of at least a couple of people. Trying to take the level to the next level? We suggest you DIY a head to carry the whole night.
29. Crooked Crow Masks Scary Rabbit Mask
BEST FOR EASTER
Yeah, we know, wrong holiday. But, incorporating familiar faces from different holidays can make for one of the scariest Halloween costumes of the year. Just check out this terrifying rabbit mask from Crooked Crow Masks on Etsy. It’s made using traditional paper mache methods and includes burlap to seal the deal. This makes for one of the scariest Halloween masks ever, so much so that kids in the neighborhood will never want to celebrate Easter again.
30. FunWorld Killer Clown Costume
It seems that people tend to either love them or hate them, but surely everyone can see how clowns are at least a little bit creepy. In the case of this FunWorld Killer Clown Complete Costume, clowns are extremely creepy. By adding evil and murderous elements, FunWorld has created a clown costume to put the fear into everyone. It’s made of a polyester jumpsuit with a ruffled collar along with a 100 percent latex mask. You can also add your choice of weapon for a more complete and terrifying outfit.
31. Disney Men’s Oogie Boogie Vinyl Mask
We’re willing to bet that if you’ve seen the Nightmare Before Christmas, you’ve always been a little scared of the Oogie Boogie Man. After all, anything that could be so cruel to Santa deserves a little fear. Bring that feeling to your Halloween party this year with this Oogie Boogie Vinyl Mask. If your friends aren’t too scared, they’ll definitely be nostalgic about their favorite animated Halloween movie.
32. Red Suit Devil Costume
BEST FOR POSH HALLOWEEN PARTIES
No party is complete without the world’s number one hated guy. He’s always up to no good, and with this Red Suit Devil Costume, you’ll be able to play that part, too. The costume includes a headpiece with horns along with pants and a jacket to create a formal incarnation of the red-bodied personification of evil from Hell. Add a pitchfork, red face paint and a pointed tail to complete this instantly recognizable outfit.
33. Rubie’s Costume Co Inflatable Evil Clown Costume
We’ve shown you a few clown costumes so far, because, you know, clowns. But, what makes this particular costume one of the creepiest clown costumes we’ve seen this year is that it’s inflatable. Because we all know, the bigger the clown, the scarier it is.
34. Adult Chucky Costume
BEST FOR SCREAMS OF SURPRISE
You might think dressing up is child’s play, and once you’ve put on this Adult Chucky Costume, you’d be absolutely correct. The kit includes a mask and jumpsuit to transform you into everyone’s favorite creepy little doll with a passion for killing. Add your choice of weapon to complete the look, and to really get into character, why not try occasionally appearing out of nowhere to give your friends a sudden fright?
35. Crooked Crow Masks Scary Weird Mask
Some of the scariest Halloween masks for men are handmade from Etsy. Like, just check out this wild-looking mask covered in raffia. With a spooky mask like this as part of your ensemble, scary Halloween costume ideas are endless. Will you be a scarecrow? Someone participating in the Purge? A burn victim covering his wounds? It’s all up to your imagination.
36. LEKA NEIL Zombie Mask
Complete any old zombie look with this realistic-looking, gory as hell mask that looks like it’s falling apart in front of your eyes. The flesh on this thing looks as if it is disintegrating from the face and sliding right off. Add the right, ripped-up, bloodied pair of Salvation Army jeans and a tee to pull this look together and make it look like you crawled right from the dead.
37. Adult Terrifying Tree Costume
Who knew trees could be so scary? This bone-chilling dead tree costume is an excellent way to scare trick-or-treaters while blending into your own landscape as the sun goes down. Simply stay turned, hide in your bushes and jump out once you hear a group of children coming up your front stoop. Trust us, this costume will have kids screaming, making it a ridiculously scary Halloween costume for men.
38. Zagone Studios Supersoft Doa Mask
Is that grandpa or a super wrinkly mask for Halloween? The world may never know. This extra-saggy mask fo Halloween is realistic enough to fool (and spook) tons of people in your neighborhood. Wear it with everyday clothing or make it even creepier by adding blood and a cloak to make it a super scary Halloween costume for men.
39. Goosebumps Slappy Adult Costume
Who didn’t love reading Goosebumps growing up? Now, the young adult books have become a series of feature films, introducing a new generation to the RL Stine classics. And, of course, everyone’s favorite character, Slappy the Dummy, plays a major role. Take on that role for yourself with the officially licensed Goosebumps Slappy Adult Costume. It includes a jacket with a flower, a pair of pants and a bow tie. Just add face paint. And, if you really want to freak your friends out, keep muttering, “Karru marri odonna lorna molanu karrano!” to see if you can bring other dummies to life, too. Plus, all of your favorite episodes from the series are now on Netflix!
40. Rubie’s Costume Screaming Corpse Overhead Mask
I’m melting, I’m melting! Although no part of this mask resembles The Wizard of Oz in the slightest, this skin-melting mask is a great response to that line. Look like each and every part of your face’s skin is melting with this terrifyingly gory mask. Maybe add a bit of fake blood and really get the ball rolling with this one!
41. California Costumes Sadistic Scarecrow Costume
BEST GROUP COSTUME
“Dorothy, where’s Toto?” It turns out Scarecrow might have eaten him, especially if this California Costumes Sadistic Scarecrow Costume is anything to go by. Of course, there’s no evidence to suggest the two are related, but this high-quality costume could easily become part of a mutated Wizard of Oz group costume. The outfit comes with a plaid shirt, a burlap style collar, a hat and a waist tie. For further gruesomeness, you could add fake blood and a pitchfork.
42. Realistic Gorilla Costume
For whatever reason, there is truly nothing scarier than a humungous gorilla charging at you in the middle of the night. It’s probably because it seems the most realistic in a way. Did it escape from a nearby zoo? Did you accidentally cross into another dimension that accidentally brought you to an African rainforest? This costume is so realistic, nobody will ever know.
43. The Goonies Sloth Mask
You can’t hate on Sloth, even if he is, well, terrifying-looking. The Goonies portrays Sloth as the classic bad guy that’s actually good, but we can’t lie, we were still absolutely spooked when first introduced to his character. If you’re trying to get some scared looks from those who don’t know and a couple of “awwwws” from those who do, throw this mask on and call it a night.
44. Inflatable Reaper Costume
We know you’re still young and (relatively) innocent, but we’re afraid it’s your time to go. In this Inflatable Reaper Costume, you’ll find that the Reaper has you in his deathly clutches and your outlook is pretty bleak. Luckily, we’re pretty sure he’s a reasonable guy and willing to let you have the whole of the Halloween night for fun before you have to head off to the other side. Add the Reaper’s famous death sickle for a more recognizable look.
45. WWE Undertaker Men’s Costume
BEST BASED ON A REAL PERSON
Usually, real people don’t make for the scariest Halloween costumes, but we’ll make an exception for the WWE Undertaker. He is the harbinger of death, after all. This costume includes everything you need to become a WWE wrestler (temporarily). It features a pair of pants, a tank top, an overcoat, a hat and a pair of gloves. You’ll just have to bring the attitude, and perhaps practice your Tombstone Piledriver before October 31 so you can really pull off the part.
46. Horrible Butcher Mask
Go above and beyond anything you’ve ever seen before with this almost demonic-looking metal-faced costume. You can do as you please with this one — become a robot-gone-wrong, a metal-worker turned serial killer or simply throw on your favorite black hoodie and call it a night.
47. Vertigo Adult Mask
Imagine this guy coming up to you alone when you’re lost on a hike? Yeah, big no thanks from us. This mask is dizzying enough to give onlookers vertigo but fits your face pretty comfortably. The look envisions a man with six eyes, three noses, two mouths and two-and-a-half-ish ears. Buy this and get ready to spook the hell out of people.
48. PartyHop Frog Mask
Ribbet . . . Ribbet . . . Go full-on amphibian for a night with this slimy-looking frog costume that takes the game to another level. You’ve probably heard of that conspiracy theory, you know, the one that explains alien reptilians have taken over the world? The most ridiculous conspiracy theory on the planet? Well, reimagine the conspiracy as if it were frogs instead and hop around your neighborhood. Start practicing your croaking now.
49. Rubie’s Deluxe Frankenstein Adult Costume
If you’re looking for a convincing Frankenstein costume this Halloween, this isn’t it. He was, in fact, the creator, not the monster. This costume is, however, a great way to look like Frankenstein’s famous creature creation. The Rubie’s Deluxe Frankenstein Adult Costume comes with everything you need to look the part, including a headpiece, a padded jacket and pants.
50. Donnie Darko Frank the Bunny Costume
In a list filled with clowns, the reaper and Michael Myers, it would seem difficult to find anything else scary enough to stand alongside these creepy creatures. That is until you lay eyes on this horrifying rabbit costume inspired by the cult classic Donnie Darko. Looking like a zombified science project seeking revenge, this full-body suit is an easy way to scare everyone (including yourself should you look in the mirror while wearing it). This costume includes a faux-fur jumpsuit, a mask and attached mitts, and it would pair well with a knife, axe or possibly a really pointy carrot for a complete and intimidating look.