Here’s Why Guys Are Opting For Shave Butter Over Shaving Cream And Gel

Best Men’s Shave Butter
Courtesy of Dollar Shave Club
When you buy something through our retail links, we may earn commission.

Shaving gel and cream have dominated the market for decades, perpetually in competition with each other for the title of Best Shaving Product. However, there’s a new kid on the block, and he’s giving the old guys a run for their money.

Originally popularized by The Dollar Shave Club, shave butter borrows benefits from other shaving products to create an innovative new go-to for your grooming routine. Shave butter is low-lather, meaning you take it out of a tube or jar and rub it directly on your face. It doesn’t foam as you rub or come pre-foamed right out of the can. This yields a few key benefits. First, this foam-less design allows shave butter to be translucent (in most cases), so you can see where and what you’re shaving. Second, the low-lather form of shave butter means it can be made with natural ingredients instead of chemicals. Third, the thicker consistency does a better job of delivering nutrients and moisture to your skin, resulting in a smooth, pain-free shave. And finally, the smooth consistency is easier on your razor, allowing the blade to glide without getting clogged.

We think every guy should give shave butter a shot, as it’s poised to take over the shaving world. There aren’t many shave butters out there yet, but we dug around and found a handful of options to choose from. Check out the best shave butter below.

1. Dr. Carver’s Easy Shave Butter

BEST OVERALL

Dr. Carver’s shave butter is responsible for kick-starting the whole trend. Once rubbed onto the skin, it’s almost completely clear so you can give yourself the most precise shave possible. It’s a Dollar Shave Club exclusive, making it easy to add to your current DSC subscription. To use the butter, squeeze a half dollar coin-sized amount onto your palm before spreading it around your face with a patting motion. Then let it sit for around 15 seconds before shaving (this is key for absorbing the nutrients).

Shave Butter Men's Dr Carver's Courtesy of Dollar Shave Club

  

2. Van der Hagen Shave Butter

BEST VALUE

Although shave butter is currently less popular than cream or gel, you can still find it for a reasonable price. This bottle from Van der Hagen is reasonably priced at just $6, and it’s also one of the best shave butters on the market. It comes highly rated from multiple outlets (4.3 stars on both Target and Amazon), and it’s a favorite here at Spy. The formula is ideal for men with sensitive skin and it has a great, clean smell. Its effectiveness is largely thanks to shea, mango and cocoa butters, as well as macadamia nut oil for added hydration. When you’re finished shaving, you can actually rub the excess shave butter into your skin as a moisturizer.

Yellow Bottle Shave Butter men's Courtesy of Target

  

3. Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Cream

HIGHEST-RATED

It’s hard to deny good reviews, and this Taylor of Old Bond Street has some of the best. It boasts over 5,000 reviews and 4.4/5 stars on Amazon, making it the highest-rated on our list. These rave reviews are thanks to a gentle formula that’s great for sensitive skin, intense moisturizing powers, and a rich scent featuring geranium, lavender, and sandalwood. Plus, you’re buying from one of the oldest grooming companies around (founded in 1854), meaning their products have been approved by generations of men.

shaving cream old fashioned sandalwood Courtesy of Amazon

  

4. Shea Moisture African Black Shave Butter

BEST CRUELTY-FREE

Some grooming products have a dark side, especially if you’re vegan or vegetarian. Animal products and testing are fairly commonplace, but it can be hard to tell when shopping around. This highly-rated shave butter, on the other hand, comes from Shea Moisture, a brand that has been open about its cruelty-free formulas and process for over 100 years. The butter is made using African black soap and a hefty amount of the brand’s signature shea butter, providing serious hydration while preventing ingrown hairs and razor bumps.

Shave Butter Men's Moisturizing Courtesy of Target

  

5. Sandalwood Shaving Kit Set For Men

BEST GIFT

Shaving isn’t like other grooming tasks — it’s a ritual that most guys really enjoy. This makes shaving kits a great gift for any well-groomed dude in your life. This year, we highly recommend a shaving kit with shave butter. First, the recipient might not know about the benefits of shave butter yet, and now he can discover this men’s grooming product in a full kit. This one from The Henna Guys includes high-quality shave butter, natural pre-shave oil, a brush, and a nice bag for gifting.

shaving kit butter brush Courtesy of Amazon

  

6. Proraso Shaving Cream

BEST UNISEX

If your girlfriend or wife often “borrows” some of your shaving products, pick up some of this shaving cream from Proraso. It’s branded for guys, but female reviewers say it makes their pits smoother than any women’s products on the market. Obviously, it delivers impressive results for men as well thanks to a fresh botanical-based formula with no harmful parabens, silicones, or artificial colors. You can use your hands, but we highly recommend investing in a shaving brush for the best results.

Shaving cream old fashioned Courtesy of Amazon

  

7. The Art of Shaving Shaving Cream

BEST FOR SENSITIVE SKIN

One of the best shaving butter products for sensitive skin, this product from The Art of Shaving has a buttery consistency and a soft formula that’s ideal for guys with sensitive skin. In fact, many Amazon reviews specifically mention that the product works wonders on sensitive skin when other products irritate. It’s a little on the pricey side, but a little bit goes a long way and the higher quality is certainly worth a few extra bucks.

shaving butter sensitive skin Courtesy of Amazon

  

8. Jack Black Supreme Cream Shave Lather

PREMIUM OPTION

When it comes to buttery shaving creams, this Jack Black supreme is the best-of-the-best. It utilizes macadamia nut oil, soy, and jojoba oil to moisturize and lift the hair away from the skin for a closer shave. It boasts three layers of hydration, translating to even fewer knicks, bumps, and burns than regular butters and creams.

expensive shaving cream jack black Courtesy of Amazon