If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SPY.com may receive an affiliate commission.
It’s a familiar story for many car buyers: a strict ban on eating and drinking in the brand new car quickly gives way to regular hamburger eating sessions and the occasionally spilled slushie. Those notoriously hard-to-clean fabric mats can suddenly become riddled with stains. What’s worse, those stains can result in odors. The optimal solution to protect your car is a rubber floor mat.
What To Consider Before Buying A Car Floor Protector
Rubber mats are often sold as “all-weather” or “all-season” mats, which generally implies that’s it’s most useful for rain and snow. But even if you live somewhere where rain is rare and snow is a myth, having an all-weather car floor protector is still a great idea. Living somewhere warm doesn’t preclude your car from dirt, and hot weather can exacerbate the bad smells that come from food and drink spills. Plus, rubber car floor protectors are easy to clean. You can pull them out and hose them down.
How We Chose the Best Car Floor Protectors
If you assumed that the only way to get an all-weather mat is to shell out for a custom one, you’d be surprised. Many all-weather car floor protectors are designed to have a universal fit, and we specifically looked for trim-to-fit designs that will suit most cars. We also looked for options with nubs on the bottom that will help the mat stay in place. The groove pattern was important too, and we looked for options that would effectively trap dirt and moisture.
Whether you’re an adventurous outdoorsman or just someone who occasionally drops their coffee order, these are some of the best car floor protectors to get right now.
1. Armor All Black Rubber Floor Mat
Armor All is best known for their liquid cleaners, but they also make great car mats. These mats are available in several colors and thicknesses, and you can choose between two, three, or four-piece sets. The bottom of this all-season mat has grips on the corners, which they call “Carpet Claws.” This prevents slippage and ensures a secure fit. The mat is designed to be trimmed to fit.
Pros: Designed to be trimmed to fit. Available in various colors and styles, including one-piece rear mats to protect the middle portion of the backseat floor.
Cons: Not wide enough for some larger vehicles.
2. Motor Trend 923-BK Black FlexTough Contour Liners
Motor Trend’s liners feature a trim-to-fit design, making it a suitable option for a wide variety of cars, trucks and SUVs. The mats have deep grooves that are designed to catch any dirt and grime. In addition to the two front mats, there’s a long rear mat that’s designed to cover the entire floor. Motor Trend’s mat is available in several colors to suit your car’s interior.
Pros: Trim to fit design suits different cars. Long rear mat to cover middle seat floor. Available in different colors. Deep groove to catch messes.
Cons: Large size means you may need to get creative when trimming to fit a smaller car.
3. FH Group Red F11311RED Rubber Floor Mat
This mat from FH Group has red color-blocking on the driver and passenger-side mats, giving them a distinctly sporty look. The edges have high buffers that effectively trap liquids, preventing them from seeping onto the carpet. Plus, the trim-to-fit design means these mats can fit a variety of car models.
Pros: Deep ridges to contain spills. Eye-catching design.
Cons: Somewhat thin.
4. Caterpillar Heavy Duty Rubber Floor Mats
These mats are made by the same company that makes construction-site heavy machinery, so it won’t come as a surprise that these are durable and have a rugged look. The most unique detail of these mats is the metal tread plate inserts, which add a tough edge to your car’s interior. The trim-to-fit design means these Caterpillar mats are suitable for a wide variety of car interiors.
Pros: Rugged design. Trim-to-fit to suit different cars. Grippy bottom to prevent slippage.
Cons: Treadplate is an aesthetic touch — it’s not actually metal.
5. Husky Liners Weatherbeater Floor Liners
Buying online makes it easy to find a customized mat to fit your car. For example, these liners from Husky are made for several crew cab models of the Dodge Ram, between 2009-2018. The mats provide full coverage for your front and back seats. The ridged design keeps your feet comfortable and your floors clean. Because these are customized liners, they ride up the edges of the floors, allowing them to more effectively keep your car clean. Husky’s liners are also made in the US.
Pros: American-made. Custom-fit. High walls prevent dirt from getting under the mat.
Cons: Not ideal if you don’t have the Dodge Ram.
6. OxGord Luxe Carpet
Rubber floor mats are rugged, but they also look rugged, which may not be ideal if your ride is a classic luxury car. These fabric mats from OxGord will protect your car’s carpet, and you can take them out for vacuuming. The mats are available in a wide array of colors. The mats have spikes on the bottom to grip the car’s carpet. The mats cover the front and rear floors.
Pros: Variety of color options. Textured panel under the pedals for a secure footing. Includes front and rear mats.
Cons: Not as easy to clean as rubber.
7. AmazonBasics Car Floor Mat
These floor mats are from Amazon’s in-house label, and the surface features a deep honeycomb design to trap dirt and spills. Available colors are black, gray, and beige. Like the other options, these mats can be trimmed to fit the size and shape of your car’s floors.
Pros: Affordable. Deeply ridged honeycomb design to trap dirt and liquids.
Cons: Takes time to off-gas. Pressure from heel can wear down the surface.