It’s a familiar story for many car buyers: a strict ban on eating and drinking in the brand new car quickly gives way to regular hamburger eating sessions and the occasional spilled slushie. Those notoriously hard to clean fabric mats can suddenly become riddled with stains. What’s worse, those stains can result in odors. The optimal solution to protect your car is a rubber floor mat.
One of the many advantages of rubber floor mats is that they’re easy to clean. If they get dirty, you can pull them out and hose them down. You can’t do that with fabric floor mats, which have to be vacuumed instead. Rubber mats are often sold as “all-weather” or “all-season” mats, which generally implies that’s it’s most useful for rain and snow. But even if you live somewhere where rain is rare and snow is a myth, having an all-weather mat is still a great idea. Living somewhere warm doesn’t preclude your car from dirt, and hot weather can exacerbate the bad smells that come from food and drink spills.
If you assumed that the only way to get an all-weather mat is to shell out for a custom one, you’d be surprised. Many all-weather mats are designed to have a universal fit. That’s because the edges can be trimmed for a more customized shape. Whether you’re an adventurous outdoorsman or just someone who occasionally drops their Starbucks order, these are some of the best car floor protectors to get right now.
1. Armor All Black Rubber Floor Mat
Armor All is best known for their liquid cleaners, but they also make great car mats. These mats are available in several colors and thicknesses, and you can choose between 2, 3, or 4 piece sets. The bottom of this all-season mat has grips on the corners, which they call “Carpet Claws.” This prevents slippage and ensures a secure fit. The mat is designed to be trimmed to fit.
Pros: Designed to be trimmed to fit. Available in various colors and styles, including one-piece rear mats to protect the middle portion of the backseat floor.
Cons: Not wide enough for some larger vehicles.
2. AmazonBasics Car Floor Mat, Black
These floor mats are from Amazon’s in-house label, and the surface features a deep honeycomb design to trap dirt and spills. Available colors are black, gray, and beige. Like the other options, these mats can be trimmed to fit the size and shape of your car’s floors.
Pros: Affordable. Deeply ridged honeycomb design to trap dirt and liquids.
Cons: Takes time to off-gas. Not the most durable — pressure from heel can wear down surface.
3. MotorTrend Rubber Floor Mats
This mat from MotorTrend comes in black, gray, beige, and clear. The mats also have trimmable edges to be able to fit in most cars. Included are two mats for the front of the car and two for the backseat, and each mat has deep ridges to contain any spills.
Pros: Thick mats with deep ridges to contain spills.
Cons: Driver’s side mat can move around somewhat.