If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SPY.com may receive an affiliate commission.
While the standard of your turkey may not make or break your Thanksgiving, a succulent, crispy-skinned showpiece will certainly gain you a lot of admiration from your guests, especially if you’re looking to establish yourself as the undisputed best Thanksgiving host in the group.
Obviously, roasting is the most popular preparation for turkey. However, no matter how you choose to cook your bird, whether roasting, grilling or deep-fat frying, ensuring your turkey ticks all the boxes requires that you cook the turkey at the right temperature, for the correct duration and in a pan designed for the job.
Turkey roasting pans come in a range of shapes and sizes, and there are several factors that determine the pan you need, including how big your turkey is, as well as the finish and moisture levels you’re looking to achieve in your Thanksgiving centerpiece. Another important factor is the presence of a rack. Roasting your turkey on a rack helps ensure the heat circulates around your bird, cooking it evenly and preventing the lower skin from becoming excessively moist.
Below you’ll find the best turkey roaster pans for chefs of every level and users with every level of budget. Choices include classic pans, disposable pans and stand-alone roasting ovens made specifically for the purpose. Find the right roaster pan for you and enjoy the most delicious turkey possible this Thanksgiving.
1. Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Rectangular Roaster
Good for turkeys, chickens and any other type of roast, the Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Rectangular Roaster is a straightforward and well-reviewed option for cooking your meat this Thanksgiving. It features a professional, stainless steel triple-ply exterior for even heat distribution along with two side-mounted handles for easy, drip-free pouring and maneuverability when things are getting hot. There’s also a stainless steel rack to help liquids drain and let your meat sit above the floor to ensure complete and even cooking all around. It’s also dishwasher safe and includes a lifetime warranty.
2. All-Clad Stainless Steel Roasting Pan With Nonstick Rack
This durable, stainless steel roasting pan helps you roast delicious and savory foods for the Thanksgiving holiday and beyond. It offers even heat conduction and comes with a V-shaped rack to promote even cooking while allowing juices to flow to the bottom for basting or gravy. The easy-grip handles make it easy to handle it as it goes in and out of the oven, and it is dishwasher safe for simple clean-up when dinner is over.
3. Reynolds Kitchens Heavy Duty Aluminum Pans
If Thanksgiving is one of the only days of the year you find yourself roasting food, these Reynolds heavy-duty aluminum pans are a great way to do it without splashing out or having to store a more permanent roaster pan you’ll never use. In addition to roasting, these aluminum pans are ideal for baking, storing and warming food as well as transporting dishes and acting as a meat tray for a barbecue. They are constructed from durable aluminum foil, which saves you from having to do the washing up after your Thanksgiving party is over.
4. Made In Blue Carbon Steel Roasting Pan
Designed with amazing heat conductivity, the Blue Carbon Steel Roasting Pan from Made In is the answer to all of your holiday roasting needs. It features high walls to easily transmit heat throughout and comes with a rack that raises its contents for easy basting and gravy making. This pan can additionally be placed on the stovetop to create a perfectly browned finish after going into the oven.
5. Cook N Home Nonstick Roaster Pan
With its included V-shaped rack for easy liquid collection and maximum airflow, the Cook N Home Nonstick Roaster Pan is an effective and budget-friendly option for roasting your turkey. The pan is made from thick aluminum, which helps distribute heat across the pan, ensuring an evenly cooked turkey. In addition to being dishwasher friendly, the non-stick interior also makes post-roast cleaning simple. Plus, the pan is large and allows for birds up to 25 pounds in size.
6. Granite-Ware Columbian Home Products 18″ Black Oval Roaster
BEST COVERED OPTION
The USA-made Granite-Ware Columbian Home Products 18″ Black Oval Roaster is constructed from heavy-duty porcelain on steel, which makes this unit both attractive and non-stick. The steel material gives the pan even heat distribution, making it ideal for successful turkey cooking. It’s also dishwasher safe and capable of holding turkeys up to 18 pounds with the lid off or 15 pounds with the lid on. If you love keeping all the juices inside your bird, this could be the choice for you. It’s also on sale right now on Walmart for under $15, which is quite the steal.
7. Viking Culinary 3-Ply Roasting Pan w/ Rack & Carving Set
BEST ROASTING SET
If you’re looking for an entire range of tools to roast your turkey, then the Viking Culinary Roasting Pan and Carving Set could be the choice for you. This comprehensive kit includes everything you’ll need to produce a delicious Thanksgiving dish. In the kit, you’ll find a roasting tray, rack, carving knife, and fork. The features a three-ply design made of a stainless steel interior, aluminum core, and induction-capable stainless exterior to provide a perfectly cook turkey for Thanksgiving day.
8. Oster Roasting Oven
BEST STANDALONE OPTION
The Oster Roasting Oven is a complete solution to roasting your turkey. This free-standing electric roaster can deliver temperatures up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and includes options to defrost and keep food warm. It’s capable of both baking and slow cooking and also includes a self-basting lid, which helps to recirculate moisture for a juicier final product. The large-sized oven can accommodate turkeys up to 26 pounds in size and comes with a removable roasting pan and rack.
9. All-in-One Cast Iron Grill
If you’re looking for a roaster that wears more than one chef’s hat, look no further than the All-in-One Cast Iron Grill from Uncommon Goods. Turn your Thanksgiving turkey into an outdoor cookout with this grill that’s able to roast, wok, smoke, skillet, braiser, deep fry, slow cook and stockpot. Meaning you can roast your turkey for dinner and deep fry some Oreos for dessert all on the same night. While this roaster should be used outdoors, the top half comes off with carrying handles for easy grill-to-table serving, which will make your Thanksgiving dinner that much easier.
10. Heiss CA-010-G/BK Cast Aluminum Roaster Pan
Add a pop of color to your Thanksgiving meal with Heiss’s roaster pans that are fit to stand out on the table. Originally created for pro chefs, Heiss’s motive is to bring that chef-level experience to the modern home with this roaster pan just about any cook can use with ease. Although this pan looks like it’s cast iron, be surprised that it isn’t in the slightest — it’s a sneakily colored aluminum. Because it’s not made from cast iron, it’s a ton lighter and more affordable. After cooking a large meal, you don’t even need to handwash this, throw it right in the dishwasher and save yourself the time. Green ain’t your jam? No worries, this roaster pan also comes in blue, black, orange, red and yellow.
11. Rachel Ray Hard-Anodized Nonstick Roaster
EASIEST TO STORE
With its hard-anodized aluminum construction, the Rachel Ray Hard-Anodized Nonstick Roaster is a durable and easy-to-store answer to roasting your Thanksgiving bird. When you don’t need it, this pan can easily fit in most under-oven drawers and will surely squeeze itself well in your pantry. The pan comes with a dual-height nonstick rack, which allows you to roast a large variety of items including meats and vegetables. Furthermore, it’s capable of withstanding temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, and the dual-riveted stainless steel handles provide an easy way to move the pan.
12. IMUSA USA Heavy Duty Cajun Oval Aluminum Roaster
An aluminum roaster this gorgeous is most certainly one to wish for, so nudge someone in your household a little bit and let them know you’re dreaming about using this for Thanksgiving dinner. The material makes the roaster perfect for fast, even heating, so you can cut your turkey roasting time a bit this year. It’s super easy to clean when the party’s over and low maintenance in total. There are handles on either side for natural transport from kitchen to dinner table, meaning you won’t have to plop the entire turkey out of the roaster when serving.
13. Calphalon Classic Roaster
Capable of housing birds or hams up to 25 pounds in size, the Calphalon Classic Roaster is a classy way to roast your dinner. The pan is made from medium-gauge, hard-anodized aluminum, which delivers even heating, while the included non-stick V-shape rack elevates your food to let liquids drain and heat circulate. The highly polished stainless steel handles make transporting the pan simple, and the non-stick interiors make the post-cooking clean up effortless. This pan is also capable of withstanding temperatures up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
14. Camerons Oval Multi Roaster
The Camerons Oval Multi Roaster is a multi-functional option, which allows you to bake, sauté and roast your food. The kit includes an 11-quart stockpot, a roasting and draining rack and a four-quart sautéing pan, which also doubles as a lid. Each item is constructed from stainless steel, and the two pans both have side-mounted handles for easy maneuverability and pouring. All products are dishwasher safe and have stick-resistant interiors.