This Pi Day, Let’s Finally Agree That Pumpkin Pie Sucks

pumpkin pie sucks
Licensed from Adobe
When you buy something through our retail links, we may earn commission and the retailer may receive certain auditable data for accounting purposes.

Happy Pi Day, nerds.

Or, should I say, happy Pi Day to everyone except those of you whose favorite pie is pumpkin-flavored. Because pumpkin pie is gross. It’s a wet, mushy mess of a pie that looks like spit-up baby food and tastes like the inside of a pumpkin.

Look at these pies:

overhead view of three pies, pecan pie, apple pie and pumpkin pie, which is gross Licensed from Adobe

Two of them look delicious. One of them looks merely edible.

Zoom in close enough, and you can’t even tell the difference between pumpkin pie filling and sweet potato baby food.

pumpkin pie filling close up Licensed from Adobe

Yet every Thanksgiving, we have to forgo actually good pies like apple, fudge, chocolate cream and pecan in favor of traditional pumpkin pie, which, I say again, is gross.

Look, if pumpkin pie was actually any good, then we would eat it all year long.

Yet I don’t see any of my local restaurants offering Pi Day pumpkin pie. The bakery at my local grocery store always has plenty of apple pies and pecan pies, yet pumpkin pie is nowhere to be seen. That’s because even for people who claim to love pumpkin pie, once per year is more than enough.

I say to you: If you have to get your pie filling out of a can, how good can it really be? Why ruin all that cinnamon, nutmeg and whip cream by polluting it with a mushy gourd? You would be better off with cinnamon rolls, cobbler or pecan pie.

Like daylight saving time or commercials on TV, it’s time to retire this mediocre pie once and for all.

This year, celebrate Pi Day with something better.