There’s nothing like the sweet, warming scent of coffee infiltrating your home in the morning as the temperatures begin to cool down. It’s a feeling we don’t get too frequently in the summertime, considering the majority of us switch to cold brew the second May 1st hits. And we all know how pricy that gets. Eat your heart out, Starbucks.
As we switch back to hot coffee for the rest of the year, there’s a good shot you’re ditching the local coffee shops and making your favorite cup of joe at home. And, unless you take your coffee black, you’re looking for a way to lighten up a bit in the form of an A1 coffee creamer.
Whether you already have your tried and true black coffee dilution in your fridge or you’re looking for a new flavor to test out, here are the best coffee creamers we’re drinking all fall and winter long.
1. International Delight Hazelnut Crème Creamer
BEST OVERALL
Maybe we’re biased, but International Delight hits in a way no other coffee creamer does. It’s a delicious enough add-in without any additional sugar and gets your coffee to your exact desired color without a problem. It’s thick and creamy which is almost the point of coffee creamer, but also completely gluten-free, lactose-free and non-GMO. There’s an array of flavor offerings from International Delight like the ever-so-popular caramel macchiato and french vanilla coffee staples, but we’ve been sold on the toasted qualities from their hazelnut option. It was love at first sip.
Related Stories
2. Coffee-Mate French Vanilla Coffee Creamer
RUNNER UP
We’re not here to stir the pot by throwing Coffee-Mate in our number two spot, just our coffee mugs. Don’t get us wrong, Coffee Mate still slaps — their french vanilla flavor hits a hell of a lot different than International Delights, not to pin two queens against each other like that. Add Coffee-Mate for a richer, smoother taste to your morning brew and you’ll regret spending your summer raiding your local Starbs every day. Although Coffee-Mate isn’t lactose-free like our good sis International Delight, she’s still gluten-free which is excellent for those who suffer from celiac disease or can’t stomach gluten the way they used to. You can also find numerous flavors online like their original flavor (which totally needs some added sugar) and their super tasty peppermint mocha concoction.
3. So Delicious Creamy Vanilla Oat Creamer
BEST NON-DAIRY CREAMER
The only good thing to rise from the ashes of 2020 is the spike in popularity of our newest favorite non-dairy milk trend. That’s right, we’re chit-chatting about oat milk. Oat milk is a way creamier option than the majority of non-dairy options on the market, but last year when the creamer option began showing its pertinence in the coffee world, stumbling on it as a milk alternative outside New York and LA was like finding a Waffle House in middle of the Atlantic Ocean. It just wasn’t going to happen, baby. Thankfully, coffee shops around the country have been adding oat milk to their creamer options all year long. Dunkin’ even got in on the trend last month by adding oat milk to their milk selection options which is wild because they don’t even have soy. Right now, we’re semi-obsessed with So Delicious’ vanilla oat creamer because of its delicious dairy-free consistency, rich and smooth texture and sweet vanilla-y taste.
4. Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte Creamer
BEST IN-SEASON CREAMER
Our prayers have been answered. Starbucks finally created a pumpkin spice latte creamer we can use right at home. Hallelujah, baby! While it doesn’t hit exactly the same way it would at your local Starbucks, this PSL creamer is a must-have for when you’re too lazy to drive to a location and when making coffee at home this fall. Maybe even grab a few to freeze just in case you’re craving some pumpkin when the season’s over. And for all you pumpkin haters out there, you know you’re wrong. This stuff is delicious and you know it.
5. Omega PowerCreamer
BEST CREAMER FOR KETO
You don’t have to cheat out on your diet anymore with the Omega PowerCreamer, which is suitable to add right into your coffee for people practicing keto or paleo diets. Not only does it have the power to totally transform your all-black cup in a way that sticks to your lifestyle, but it also works as a scrumptious additive for smoothies and shakes. The creamer is made from grass-fed ghee and other health-conscious ingredients to ensure you’re only getting 100% healthy fats when adding this to your cup of joe. Omega PowerCreamer even promotes lasting energy and focus throughout your entire day. So, your coffee high will only be doubled — and we love that!
6. Laird Superfood Coffee Creamer
BEST POWDER
We can’t tell you the amount of creamer we’ve wasted simply because we don’t drink it all in time. It’s such a dang shame. Thankfully, that’ll never be the case with this coffee creamer from Laird Superfood. While some might be a bit skeptical to try out a non-liquid coffee creamer, know that there’s nothing to be afraid of. This powder mixes in just as well as any ‘ole liquid alternative and doesn’t even need the refrigerator. This creamer option is a fantastic one considering it’s even dairy-free, gluten-free, vegan, soy-free & non-GMO. Excuse us while we catch our breath. There are no fillers or additives and it’s also completely keto. So, if you’re looking for a creamer that has the ability to do it all, don’t fear powder.
7. Splenda Sweet Cream Coffee Creamer
BEST SUGAR-FREE
You either love Splenda or hate it. There really isn’t much of an in-between. But for you sugar-free lovers out there, you might be surprised to learn that Splenda has their own sweet cream coffee creamer for purchase right on Amazon that actually tastes quite good. It’s rich and creamy in its consistency, sweet and totally sugar-free. If you don’t feel the need to add any extra Splenda packets into your cup, this creamer is an awesome sugar-free alternative to your regular milk and Splenda cup. At only 15 calories per serving, this creamer is also one of the lowest cal options here, too, yet is still jam-packed with tons of flavor.
8. nutpods Variety 4 pack
BEST UNSWEETENED
Although almond milk is on sort of a downward trajectory after so many non-dairy milk alternatives have hit the scene, we have to suggest you try nutpods before turning away for good. This almond and coconut blend creamer option is an absolutely scrumptious way to beef up your coffee without any added sweeteners. Unlike most almond and coconut creamer alternatives, nutpods is actually a bit thicker and richer than any other option on the market. It’s also fit for most diets including keto, paleo, vegan, kosher and more. Each flavor is quite delicious, but pick your favorite yourself with this four-pack featuring original, french vanilla, hazlenut and caramel.
9. Coffee-Mate Liquid Variety Pack
BEST CUPS
Although we’ve already conquered Coffee-Mate, we couldn’t leave out this 180 cup variety pack featuring six of their incredible flavors. As your token stolen item from any hotel lobby or diner visit, we’re thinking, why don’t you just buy some cups for yourself, you little thief? You’re going to buy creamer anyway. As mentioned, Coffee-Mate is delicious and gluten-free. Unlike the larger variety, these tiny cups don’t even have to be refrigerated, which is great, because imagine trying to find a place for these in your tiny fridge? We aren’t the Kardashians. Packed with their iconic hazelnut, french vanilla, vanilla caramel, cinnamon vanilla creme, Irish creme and original flavors, expect around 30 of each to last you the entire winter.
10. Dunkin’ Donuts Extra Extra Coffee Creamer
BEST NAME BRAND
Starbucks drinkers might consider Dunkin’ to be the Walmart to their Prada, but we can’t hate on what keeps America running. Dunkin’ is killer. If you’re staying inside more frequently and haven’t had your Dunkin’ fix in a bit, snag their Extra Extra coffee creamer to keep in your fridge when you’re craving your go-to cup. This bottle is packed with real cream and sugar, and because it’s called “Extra Extra”, keep in mind that Dunkin’ doesn’t skimp out in the slightest. The creamer is thick, sweet and smooth, which is perfect for a chilly morning inside.
11. milkadamia Macadamia and Coconut Creamer
NEWEST TREND
First, we had coconut, then we had almond, now we’re onto oat. Next on our radar, macadamia. It’s like you can milk just about anything these days. Though oat milk is still taking over the world of coffee, milkadamia’s macadamia and coconut creamer isn’t pacing too far behind. After giving it a try ourselves, we’re surprised to say it’s quite creamy and smooth. Being not only dairy-free, but also plant-based, vegan, dairy-free, soy-free, gluten-free, carrageenan-free, non-GMO, kosher and, potentially the best part of all, just 15 calories per serving, this is a coffee creamer you should definitely add to your list.