There’s something so comforting about a freshly brewed cup of joe. But making that coffee on rushed mornings, or waiting in lines for an expensive blend can be exhausting. Keurig machines offer the ultimate blend of convenience and quality with the simple press of a button.
The best Keurig pods mimic the flavor of fresh coffee, but churn out a cup much faster, without the mess of heating water and measuring grains. Settings can be customized according to taste, so the strength and heat level delivers a flawless cup every time. From different levels of roast to sustainable pods, there are endless options available. Take a look at our suggestions, which we break down into sections for easy digestion.
Buy pods in bulk and never worry about the local coffee shop running out of your favorite flavor, or surpassing your beverage budget for the week. We studied them all and compiled the highest quality Keurig pods for every coffee lover’s palate, so you can stay fuelled for the rest of 2021.
Best Variety Pack
Peet’s Coffee Variety Pack, 40-Count
Peet’s Coffee is the holy grail of Keurig pods, and this offering serves up an ideal amount of variety. This 40-pack comes with a dark roast house blend, a medium roast, and a light roast. There aren’t any fancy frills or artificial flavors here — just good coffee that tastes fresh. The dark roast is beautifully full-bodied and seems to be the star of this pack, but the other two blends garner excellent reviews as well with all three reaching the “perfect balance of flavor and strength.”
Keurig Coffee Lovers’ Collection Variety Pack, 40-Count
Some of us thrive on a routine, and others feel stuck in one. If you frequently find yourself trying a new flavor at your local cafe or getting sick of your coffee at home, this sampler pack by Keurig will ensure that you never get bored. There are 40 different options of various roasts, including the popular cinnamon roll flavored pods by Cinnabon. Many variety packs are about flashiness, but the brands used here are all premium, despite a low price point.
Solimo Assorted Pack, 100-count
If you like variety but don’t want to spend a fortune, Solimo offers 100 pods for under $30. This assorted pack offers plenty of variety, with a light roast, dark roast, and flavored option. It’s not the most groundbreaking cup you’ll ever taste, but the smooth finish of these 100% Arabica pods are described as excellent value for the money by most reviewers. If you’re not a coffee snob and simply require a morning pick-me-up, Solimo serves that purpose without question.
Crazy Cups Single Serve & K Cups Variety Pack, 40-count
You can opt for the Crazy Cups flavored pack, or a non-flavored option which contains a diverse blend of different roasts, from French to Italian. If you’re still trying to figure out what your favorite coffee is, this is a superb way to test drive an assortment of flavors and well known brands, such as Caribou, Starbucks, Green Mountain, and Donut Shops. Users enjoyed certain flavor innovations like Chocolate Coconut Dream, while more unusual ones, like Banana, weren’t as satisfying.
Best Light Roast K-Cups
The Organic Coffee Co. Breakfast Blend, 36-Count
If you usually find that the average coffee bean tastes a little harsh, a light roast can offer a less intense version that’s just as pleasant to sip on. The Organic Coffee Co offers a breakfast blend in biodegradable packaging. It’s versatile with different Keurig models (including the 2.0) and leaves significantly less of an aftertaste than similar Keurig pods by other brands. Anything you select by this brand is organic, which means more antioxidants and minerals in your daily dose of java.
Starbucks Blonde Roast Veranda Blend K-Cup Pods, 32-Count
If you love your Starbucks but not the price tag of their in-cafe options, consider the Keurig line by Starbucks. This 40-count works with both the original Keurig and the 2.0. Some people think that the Starbucks coffee has a “burnt” taste to a few of their blends, but most agree that the blonde roast lightens things up very pleasantly.
Victor Allen Coffee K-Cup Light Roast Morning Blend, 80-count
This light-bodied roast is one of Victor Allen’s most balanced blends, and is often compared to an Italian roast. It has a crispy acidity and bright flavor profile that’s synonymous with most light roasts. One reviewer turned to this brew after being disappointed with the burnt-tasting coffee at Starbucks. It’s mellow in nature with caramel undertones but doesn’t sacrifice strength, making this a hot contender for anyone with a Keurig.
Best Medium Roast
Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend Keurig K-Cup Pods, 72-Count
Many of us crave a robust cup of coffee, but that often comes with a price of high acidity levels. Say goodbye to bitterness forever with Caribou’s smooth, low-acid blend. Coming in at just over $0.40/pod, the Caribou Blend carries notes of cocoa, cedar, and berry, with a profile that finds the middle ground between spicy and sweet. Unlike similar products that are on the market, you won’t find coffee grains at the bottom of your cup.
Dunkin’ Donuts Original Blend Medium Roast Keurig K-Cup Pods, 60-Count
If you don’t rock with Starbucks, you’re just might be a die-hard Dunkin’ fan. This 60-pack comes with their original medium roast – a balanced and invigorating brew that’s not overly intense. Made from Arabica beans, you can make everything from an affogato to an iced cappuccino. The ultimate sidekick for your morning donut break – multiple reviewers call if their favorite k-cup.
McCafe Premium Medium Roast, 84-Count
Even people who don’t eat fast food will pull up to the McDonalds drive-through for their surprisingly robust and high-quality java. Their premium roast is just as delicious in the form of k-cup pods, and embodies the true definition of “medium roast.” It lacks the bitterness that many people observe about Starbucks coffee, but still has some oomph to it.
CozyUp Medium Roast Colombian Coffee, 76-Count
If you’re going to opt for a medium roast, choosing Colombian beans is a foolproof move. It’s always strong but just sweet enough, with caramel and cocoa notes. The most popular Colombian blend is by Green Mountain, but a lesser-known brand known as CozyUp is the underdog that you should be paying attention to. Buyers note that the cups are sturdy, and the pods have “great flavor’ and “so much better than others in its class.”
Best Dark Roast
Newman’s Own Organics French Roast, 72-Count
We love French roasts for their velvety smooth but rich texture. Many people complain about French roasts tasting burnt or chalky, but Newman’s got their formula down to a T. The organic blend is hearty enough to call a dark roast, yet still mild enough to go down easy. Made with Fair Trade Certified beans, Newman’s also donates proceeds to charities.
Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic Keurig K-Cup Pods, 72-Count
Green Mountain Coffee Roasters has been a mainstay in the beverage world for years, and their dark roast pods are an underrated force of nature. Many coffee drinkers who purchased this choice were sick of the “burnt roasted beans” taste that many so-called dark roasts can quickly take on. These beans offer an extra bold (but not bitter) flavor that’s well-developed and won’t leave you with a bad taste in your mouth.
Cafe Bustelo Coffee Espresso Style Dark Roast, 72-count
Cafe Bustelo has always had a formidable presence in the coffee world. It packs a satisfying punch that many comparable brews simply can’t. For those feeling nostalgic about Cuban coffee, Bustle is a no-brainer with true flavor. Many Bustelo lovers admit that after they tried their first cup of Cafe Bustelo, they never turned back to other brands.
Roastmaster Reserve Organic Dark Roast Coffee, 50-count
This rare single-origin dark roast is offered a limited batch, which is perhaps why it has so many stellar reviews on Amazon. It’s strong and satisfying, but never bitter, as some dark roasts can be. Many credit this to pods being organic and blended with a subtle cane sugar sweetness. If you’re looking for an impeccable dark blend that won’t break the bank, this coffee from Papua New Guinea will unexpectedly delight you, in any beverage size.
Best Decaf K-Cups
Tayst Decaf Defiantly Decaf Coffee Pods, 30-Count
Tayst serves up a decaf coffee pod that has a gourmet taste, with a minimal carbon footprint. Although it doesn’t contain caffeine, you wouldn’t be able to guess it from the rich, hearty composition of these pods. One user compares to the bitterness of a Starbucks drink and the blandness of supermarket pods, suggesting this product as an alternative that’s “a perfect medium.” If caffeine gives you the jitters, an upset stomach, or keeps you up all night, consider Tayst.
Green Mountain Coffee Half-Caff, 72-Count
This isn’t exactly decaffeinated, but it only contains half the intensity. When you don’t want to get too amped up from your usual cup of Joe, but a decaf won’t get the job done, turn to half-caff. This Green Mountain blend is made with half the caffeine level of an average cup. It’s perfect if you’re sensitive to caffeine or trying to watch your intake, and the price is significantly cheaper than the same pods at local brick-and-mortar stores.
Eight O’Clock Coffee Original Decaf Medium Roast, 72-count
Maybe you can’t tolerate caffeine at all or are too sensitive to have more than one cup of java a day. Either way, this Keurig brand has your back on a delicious refill that won’t give you the jitters or an upset stomach. Its complex flavor profile is neither bitter nor overly mellow, but most importantly, it’s not watered down like some decaf blends (or as one coffee lover calls it, “brown water masquerading as coffee”) and is even better quality than some caffeinated alternatives.
Best Flavored K-Cups
Folgers Caramel Drizzle Flavored, 96-Count
Flavor shots can turn a mediocre coffee into something superb, and users describe the taste of Folgers Caramel Coffee as being similar to a vanilla biscotti, which doesn’t sound too shabby. It’s not the easiest Folgers flavor to find in stores and helps you save by buying in bulk. The composition is slightly nutty and creamy, and buyers love how it fills a room with an addictive caramel aroma — no candle needed.
The Original Donut Shop Mocha Latte, 20-Count
A latte is one of those indulgences that can seem so necessary at times. In the winter, it heats you up with frothy, steamed goodness. In the hotter months, an iced version will invigorate you like no other. This mocha latte by The Original Donut Shop lets you enjoy every sip, without the guilt of a hefty coffeeshop price tag. This pod is filled with a pre-measured amount of flavoring, and sweetener, and is also made with real milk.
Cinnabon Classic Cinnamon Roll, 48-count
A Cinnabon is a gooey treat that we all dream of once in a while, but if you want to experience that same warm and comforting indulgence without the calories, try it in K-cup form. Surprisingly, this dessert-inspired pod isn’t overly sweet or artificial tasting. It has a gentle cinnamon infusion is a light roast that is swirled with the lusciously frosted flavor of a Cinnabon, without any added sugar. It has an authentic cinnamon bun flavor, with a sweetness level that’s completely customizable.
Grove Square Cappuccino, French Vanilla 50-count
If fresh-brewed coffee isn’t your thing, these caffeinated pods taste just like a cappuccino infused with French Vanilla flavor. Buyers find that unlike other flavored pods, these are naturally sweet and creamy, so you never have to add your own sugar packets or creamer. If you’re looking to make guests or family a quick and satisfying morning beverage, this is hands down the easiest pod to serve , given its low maintenance nature – no prep necessary!
Best Eco-Friendly K-Cups
Joe Knows Coffee, Tall Dark and Handsome Pods, 40-count
If no one else can sweep you off your feet, these compostable Tall, Dark and Handsome pods by Joe Knows Coffee will get the job done. For those who complain about pod flavor being too weak, this 40-count box carries an undeniably bold flavor. If you’re on the hunt for reliable pods that are environmentally friendly, Joe Knows Coffee will check all your boxes. Along with being eco-friendly, the brand is partnered with Grounds for Health, a non-profit that supports women’s health.
SF Bay OneCup Coffee Organic Rainforest Blend, 120-count
Not only are these pods commercially compostable, but this top-rated blend of theirs is fully organic. It’s noteworthy that everything from the outer bag to the one-way coffee valve is made from completely plant-based materials. Some eco-friendly brands still use some plastic packaging, but as of 2019, the SF Bay pods are entirely compostable, with zero plastic. Users appreciate the price value for an impressively fresh taste, which one buyer calls “the best coffee that comes out of a Keurig machine“.
Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods, 12-count
These Hawaiian K-pods get our vote due to the fact that you’re not drinking heated-up plastic in your coffee, which is unfortunately the case with many other pods on the market. Amazon reviewers sing their praises on this product, calling both taste and aroma “intoxicating and fresh” when compared to the chemical aftertaste that certain pods can carry. Kauai’s k-cups are made with 35% less plastic than other pods, letting the rich and nutty flavor shine through more effectively.