Works well for all sleeping positions, provides the classic, cushioning feel of memory foam.
Not recommended for those who want a firmer mattress or who prefer innerspring coils.
Great option for hot sleepers, great option for couples, provides optimal pressure point relief.
Not recommended for those who prefer a traditional innerspring or memory foam feel.
Helps relieve joint pain, great for athletes and those who live an excellent lifestyle, good for hot sleepers.
Not recommended for side sleepers, not the best choice for couples.
Great mattress for couples, recommended for hot sleepers, works well for combination sleepers.
Not recommended for those who prefer a traditional innerspring feel.
Helps relieve shoulder pain, works well for couples, works well for side sleepers, back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and combination sleepers.
Not the best option for couples, not recommended for those who prefer the traditional memory foam mattress feel.
The products featured in this article have been independently reviewed by the Mattress Advisor team in partnership with SPY. When you buy something through the retail links on this page, we may earn commission at no cost to you, the reader.
As you seek a great night’s sleep, one of the most important investments you can make is a new mattress. And thankfully, today’s bed-in-a-box mattress brands offer high standards of comfort, support, and durability for disruptively low price points. In fact, you can get a high-quality, long-lasting mattress for under $2,000.
The question is, which affordable mattress product is right for you? It depends on several factors, including your body type, sleeping position, and comfort preference. In this mattress comparison guide, we’ll walk you through some of the best mattresses under $2000.
1. Best Overall Mattress Under $2,000: Casper Mattress
The Casper mattress is an excellent choice no matter your preferred sleeping position. It offers a contouring effect for side sleepers and ample support for those who sleep on their back or stomach. In our testing, we found that it’s a great pick for combination sleepers, too. Note also that this high-quality mattress has four layers of memory foam, and that each memory foam layer offers targeted lumbar support and pressure point relief.
Pros: Works well for all sleeping positions, provides the classic cushioning feel of memory foam.
Cons: Not recommended for those who want a firmer mattress, or who prefer innerspring coils.
2. Helix Midnight Luxe
We love hybrids because they combine all the best features of other mattress types. The Helix Midnight Luxe earns the runner up title, primarily thanks to its unique design. The zoned support of innerspring coils combined with the cushioning and pressure relief of memory foam truly deliver a sleep experience like no other. As an added bonus, its breathable mattress design makes it a great option for hot sleepers.
Pros: Great option for hot sleepers, great option for couples, provides optimal pressure point relief.
Cons: Not recommended for those who prefer a traditional innerspring or memory foam feel.
3. Bear Mattress
BEST FOR ATHLETES
Does your active lifestyle leave you with sore joints, stiff muscles, or constant aches and pains? You may want to try sleeping on a Bear, our top choice for relieving stiffness and pain. It’s made with a Celliant cover, which converts body heat to infrared energy. Not only does this promote blood flow, but it also helps you sleep cool.
Pros: Helps relieve joint pain, great for athletes and those who live an excellent lifestyle, good for hot sleepers.
Cons: Not recommended for side sleepers, not the best choice for couples.
4. Saatva Zenhaven Mattress
BEST FOR COUPLES
If you share your bed with a partner, then it’s important to look for a mattress with a high motion isolation score. The ZenHaven is one of the best bets for motion transfer, which means if you get up to use the bathroom in the night, or simply toss and turn, you won’t stir your partner to wake. We recommend this Saatva product as one of the best mattresses for couples. Optimal edge support and white glove delivery sweeten the deal.
Pros: Great mattress for couples, recommended for hot sleepers, works well for combination sleepers.
Cons: Not recommended for those who prefer a traditional innerspring feel.
5. Brooklyn Signature Mattress
Are you better off with a firm mattress, a plush mattress, or something in the medium-firm range? When looking for the best mattress under $2,000, why settle for just one? The Brooklyn Signature offers all three options, letting you pick the firmness level that fits your body type and sleep position. What this means is that the Brooklyn Signature is ideal for all sleep positions. Stomach sleepers will want something firmer, side sleepers the softest option, and back sleepers the one in between. We’ve tested all three options and can vouch that they all offer plenty of comfort and support.
Pros: Helps relieve shoulder pain, works well for couples, works well for side sleepers, back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and combination sleepers.
Cons: Not the best option for couples, not recommended for those who prefer the traditional memory foam mattress feel.
6. DreamCloud Mattress
BEST FOR HEAVIER SLEEPERS
We love the DreamCloud because it supports all body types; we’ve tested it thoroughly and can confirm that it’s comfy for plus-sized sleepers. And, it offers a true luxury experience, including the option of white-glove setup and old mattress removal. Our testing also finds that the DreamCloud is comfy and cool for all sleeping positions.
Pros: Great choice for seniors, provides relief for lower back pain, great for all sleep positions.
Cons: Doesn’t offer the classic memory foam feel.
7. Cocoon Chill Mattress
BEST FOR HOT SLEEPERS
Nobody likes waking up with the night sweats, or feeling like their bed retains too much body heat. When we test any luxury mattress product, we’re always alert to how cool it feels, and the Cocoon Chill is one of the best cooling mattresses we’ve ever come across. Its cooling cover is made with phase change materials, helping to regulate your body temperature and prevent you from overheating. A polyfoam comfort layer enhances comfort and promotes motion isolation, meaning this is also a great pick for couples. All around, Cocoon Chill is one of the coolest options you’ll find.
Pros: Works well for hot sleepers, suits all sleeping positions, excellent motion isolation makes it a good pick for couples.
Cons: Doesn’t support heavier sleepers.
8. Nolah Original 10″
BEST FOR SIDE SLEEPERS
Different types of mattresses accommodate different sleeping positions. Our testing finds that the Nolah Original 10” is especially well-suited for side sleeping, due in large part to its excellent spine alignment. This is a quality mattress that will help side sleepers maintain a healthy posture all through the night. Other bonuses: Great edge support and minimal sagging; and, excellent responsiveness, which means it’s a good choice for combination sleepers, too.
Pros: Superior spine alignment makes it ideal for side sleepers, great for couples.
Cons: Doesn’t score as well in pressure point relief.
9. Puffy Mattress
BEST MEMORY FOAM
Some sleepers just want that classic, cushioning feel of memory foam. If that’s you, then we recommend the Puffy. We love its three support layers, which help cradle you to sleep each night. Its supple support makes the Puffy a good mattress for side sleepers, couples, and anyone who struggles with back and joint pain. Plus, Puffy offers industry-leading customer service.
Pros: Great for couples, great for side sleepers, provides relief for back and joint pain.
Cons: Not recommended for those who want a plush mattress.
10. Amerisleep AS3
BEST FOR COMBINATION SLEEPERS
What do we mean when we talk about combination sleepers? Basically, we mean people who tend to toss, turn, and change positions during the night. These sleepers need a highly responsive sleeping surface that adapts and adjusts to their movement, and the Amerisleep AS3 more than delivers. As an added bonus, its Celliant cover helps you with body heat regulation. Also note that the Amerisleep AS3 is made with quality materials, including foam layers set at the medium-firm sweet spot.
Pros: Celliant cover promotes blood flow and helps you stay cool, excellent edge support.
Cons: Not the best choice for combination sleepers.
No matter which type of mattress you’re looking for, you can find a high-quality design without venturing into the high-end price range. In short, you really can buy a premium, top-rated mattress for under $2,000. We can vouch for all of the products on this list, and would encourage you to do your research and sign up for a sleep trial soon. A good night’s sleep awaits you.
- Casper — Best Overall
- Helix Midnight Luxe — Runner Up
- Bear — Best for Athletes
- Zenhaven — Best for Couples
- Brooklyn Signature — Best Customizable
- DreamCloud — Best for Heavier Sleepers
- Cocoon Chill — Best for Hot Sleepers
- Nolah Original 10″ — Best for Side Sleepers
- Puffy — Best Memory Foam
- Amerisleep AS3 — Best for Combination Sleepers
Josh Hurst lives and writes in Knoxville, TN. A recovering insomniac, he has a long-standing appreciation for the power of a good night’s sleep.
Why Trust Spy?
SPY.com is a discovery and reviews platform, connecting you with the latest tech, style, smart gadgets and health and grooming staples you can’t find elsewhere.