The Best Shaving Cream For Men Doesn’t Come in a Can, Guys

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SPY.com may receive an affiliate commission.

The finer things in life come in many forms. For the modern man, that could be a smooth, clean-cut shave. While many guys feel they have this grooming ritual mastered, the truth is most are still at the amateur level, slicing up their face or enduring excessive inflammation that’s often mistaken for sunburn. You’re thinking a new blade will solve these skincare problems, but it takes two to tango, which is why having the right men’s shaving cream is just as important for ensuring the best (and safest) shave possible.

Before you jump online and buy just any shaving cream listed on Amazon’s Best Sellers page, you need to know which of the best shaving creams for men really are the best shaving creams for men. This will help you maintain a blemish-free mug and protect your skin, which is also vital for you manscaping gents out there.

Recent Comments

Add Comment

6 People Commenting

jamesdukes054

4 years

It's really great to see this "Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap" thanks for sharing :)

Mark

5 years

Your title reads that you have some shaving creams and that the MEN are under $20.

When ranking the best shaving cream, we start with the ingredients list. Know that the majority of skincare products have preservatives that aid with performance and extend their shelf life but also increase the risk of serious health issues when used in high concentrations. Try your best to avoid the ingredients on the no-no list below when shopping for a top-of-the-line men’s shaving cream:

Recent Comments

Add Comment

6 People Commenting

jamesdukes054

4 years

It’s really great to see this “Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap” thanks for sharing :)

Mark

5 years

Your title reads that you have some shaving creams and that the MEN are under $20.

• Parabens: Chemicals and preservatives that can increase skin aging and trigger reproductive health issues.
• Emulsifiers: May cause eye or skin irritation and is also linked to hormone disruption.
• Phthalates: Endocrine disruptors linked to asthma, male fertility issues, type II diabetes and several other ailments.
• Mineral oil: A petroleum byproduct that blocks pores and increases the risk of skin irritation.
• Sulfates: Can lead to numerous health problems such as cognitive impairment, cell mutation, dermatitis, and nerve damage.
• Benzene: A solvent that affects the immune system and may result in anemia, or worse, leukemia.

Oh, one other thing: toss out that aerosol shaving foam can that’s been sitting underneath your sink for years. A lot of the cheap drug store shaving creams are loaded with harmful chemicals. Maybe you’ve grown attached to your bargain shave cream, but some of the premium options on this list cost as little as $4 or $8 and last for three months or more. A little of these quality shave creams go a long way.

Now that we’re past the beginner’s course, let’s enroll you into Shaving 102: Picking the Best Shaving Cream for Men. Get your best body groomer and deliciously-smelling aftershaves ready as we browse through the market’s top options based on budget, occasion, and of course, skin type.

1. Dollar Shave Club Shave Gel

BEST OVERALL

Okay, technically, this stellar Dollar Shave Club product is a shaving gel, not a shaving cream, but it lathers up just the same, and the SPY grooming team is unanimous that this is the best product for shaving, full stop. We named this the best shaving cream for men in The 2021 Man, our end-of-year product awards, and we still firmly believe it’s a perfect product. The formula is safe for sensitive skin and helps moisturize as you shave, which is a great counter-effect to the irritation shaving can cause.

Dollar Shave Club uses soothing aloe vera juice and shea butter, which work together to nourish your skin. For guys seeking the ultimate close shave, this shave gel is your new secret weapon. We’re big fans of Dollar Shave Club, but even if you aren’t interested in becoming a member, we strongly recommend you replace your drug store shaving cream with this excellent shave gel.

2. Pacific Shaving Co. Caffeinated Shaving Cream

RUNNER UP

Caffeine is more than just a stimulant to increase wakefulness and concentration — it can also keep skin looking healthy and youthful. Hence why Pacific Shaving Co. deemed it suitable for its organic formula, which is made from safe, natural ingredients. No, your face won’t smell like a Starbucks, but you’ll feel the effects of this antioxidant-rich supplement on your skin such as mild tightness. Your nostrils will also take in a minty scent that’s calming for shavers with unsteady hands. If you prefer grooming products with an all-natural ingredient list, then this is the shaving cream for you.

PSC has a caffeine-free version that is just as rewarding and offers the two options in TSA-sized packaging, so you can get the same quality shave while traveling. I highly recommend the caffeinated shaving set with bundled aftershave, which is excellent and delivers the perfect balance of coolness and hydration; it can be used as a face lotion too.

3. Jack Black Supreme Cream Triple Cushion Shave Lather 

BEST FOR SKIN PROTECTION

Even the most seasoned shaver draws blood on occasion. Since shaving cuts are unpredictable, the best security measure you can take to minimize them is investing in a personal grooming product that’s formulated to play nicely with your shaving tools. Enter Jack Black’s Supreme Cream. It uses the company’s patented Triple Cushion technology to create a thick, moisturizing layer for razors to effortlessly glide across the face without gunking up the blades or nicking the skin. The mix of glycerin, macadamia nut oil and soybean oil is also effective for preventing xeroderma (aka dry skin) and the formation of wrinkles.

4. Cremo Cooling Shave Cream

BEST COOLING

It’s fair to question any shaving cream marked $5 or lower — unless it’s made by Cremo. The beloved shaving brand takes its original formula, which has been specifically engineered to reduce cuts, nicks, scrapes and irritation, and adds cooling elements into the mix (e.g. peppermint, menthol, tea tree oil) for one hell of a refreshing shave. Its texture is so slick that most men can comfortably shave against the grain without any trouble, plus the clear white strip it produces is thin for multiple-blade razors to move seamlessly across the skin. You can grab a double pack right now and get more for your money.

5. Harry’s Shave Cream

BEST SUBSCRIPTION SHAVE

Living an active lifestyle can lead you to forget about restocking the simplest things, such as shaving cream. That’s where a Harry’s subscription becomes clutch. The monthly shave club not only replenishes you with new blades for your trusty Truman razor but comes with other shaving essentials as well, including its popular shave gel or cream. Honestly, you can’t go wrong with either; however, Harry’s Shave Cream does fare better than most Pharmacy-favorited options. Harry’s formula is paraben- and sulfate-free and delivers solid lubrication that works favorably with the brand’s five-blade system.

While Harry’s loses out to Dollar Shave Club when it comes to the best shaving cream, nothing shaves better than Harry’s Truman razor kit. If you want to pair the best shaving creams with the best men’s razor, then Harry’s is our top pick.

6. Truefitt & Hill 1805 Shave Cream

LUXE PICK

For a 007-esque shave, splurge on Truefitt & Hill 1805. This $30 shaving cream has a velvety slickness to it when lathered with a fine shaving brush, spreading effortlessly across the face and spoiling your skin (and nostrils) with a tantalizing oceanic scent that is truly one of a kind. Very little is required to take care of bushy faces, plus its creamy texture protects sensitive areas for close cuts, which is something straight razor conformists will appreciate. After one shave, your partner won’t be able to keep their hands off your soft and smooth moneymaker. 

7. Fabric Shave Cream

BEST FOR BEARD MAINTENANCE

For the fella who refuses to chop off his Movember fuzz, while still trying to keep it looking fresh on the edges, this is the product you want sitting next to your beard trimmer kit. The all-new subscription box service, Fabric, sells an assortment of personal grooming products for men with high-quality ingredients at a low cost, though we’re partial to the brand’s shaving cream. Squeezing out a dollop reveals a silver strip that turns translucent when wet and becomes sudsy, similar to a facial cleanser. It rubs gently onto skin and dampens both stubble and thick strands, granting shavers smooth strokes when shaping the corners of their beards. FYI: committing to a Fabric subscription earns you an extra 10% off purchases.

8. Proraso Sensitive Shaving Cream

BEST FOR SENSITIVE SKIN

The market has plenty of shaving creams for sensitive skin, but Proraso’s shaving lubricant is arguably the best of the batch, offering stellar performance at a reasonable price. A dollop is enough to comfort skin with coolness and hydration, combating redness and razor burn in the process. Lathering is simple and produces a thick, rich layer that relieves sensitive spots when gently applied. Lastly, the product features unique ingredients like oatmeal extract and green tea that act as emollients to soften and soothe skin.

9. Blade Runner Energizing Shave Cream

MOST REVITALIZING

Boost your energy with a shaving cream that will help you feel ready to take on the day. Blade Runner’s energizing shaving cream is great for the kind of guy who has a hard time waking up in the morning. When you’re yawning through your morning shave, slap on this shaving cream made with skin-softening kukui nut oil and smoothing soybean oil for a close shave each time. With invigorating scents mixed in such as eucalyptus, peppermint and coriander, you’ll be awake and out of the house in no time.

10. Kiehl’s Ultimate Brushless Shave Cream White Eagle

BEST FROM KIEHL’S

Since 1851 Kiehl’s has dominated the skincare space, so it should come as no surprise that the brand has a killer shaving cream for guys to get gliding. This shaving cream is made with a formula perfect for an ultra-smooth finish, including menthol, camphor and sesame oil as the key ingredients. You don’t even need any water, just lather on a small dollop and get shaving.

11. Billie Shave Cream

BEST GENDER NEUTRAL

Deemed the last shave cream you’ll ever need, Billie’s shave cream mixes shea butter and olive oil to create a no-foam, soothing cream that keeps your skin feeling smooth even after you wash your face. Razors find 0 difficulties combating tough hairs on your face with such a buttery texture. It’s a genderless shaving cream option that you’re probably going to have to hide from any ladies living in your house. We want this one all to ourselves.

12. Malin+Goetz Vitamin E Shaving Cream

BEST LIGHTWEIGHT

Lightweight, foamless creams are ideal for guys looking to upkeep and shape their facial hair. Why you ask? Because the consistency allows you to actually be able to see what you’re doing when you’re shaving. Malin+Goetz’s foam alternative doesn’t block the skin during the shaving process and is packed with vitamin E and amino acids for a smooth, soothing shave. It rinses without leaving any residue behind, so quick two-minute morning shaves before work is more than possible with this cream.

13. The Art of Shaving Bourbon Shaving Cream

BEST BOURBON FRAGRANCE

You have to give credit where it’s due, and it’s been due to The Art of Shaving for a very long time. The luxury shaving retailer has stepped up its grooming game to become a category leader, creating exceptional shaving creams, none more impressive than its bourbon-infused offering. We’ve previously rated this product as the best of all men’s shaving cream, but in recent months, we’ve grown tired of all the bourbon-infused grooming products on the market (do we really want to smell like bourbon?)

Still, there’s no denying the quality of the product. Very little is needed to develop a rich, foamy lather, which provides great cushioning for blades to slide comfortably across the face without nicking it. The high concentration of glycerin blesses the shaving surface with a nice amount of moisturization that stimulates a sense of comfort when applied. Hints of cask-aged bourbon also stick to the skin, awarding shavers with a manly rugged scent (don’t worry, you won’t smell like you just came from the bar).

14. Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream 

BEST TRADITIONAL SHAVE CREAM

Old-timers who enjoy a clean barbershop-like shave can have just that with this classic shaving option. The legacy UK grooming brand sells a variety of different shaving creams in different scents, but we’re most fond of this particular version. It whips up into a dense lather that feels far more luxurious than other competitors in its price class. When applied, your face is met with a unique, masculine scent that’s dominated by sandalwood, along with subtle hints of patchouli, powdery musk and rock rose. 

15. Every Man Jack Fragrance-Free Shaving Cream

BEST FOR TRAVEL

A great travel-sized, fragrance-free shaving cream made from natural ingredients sounds like a hard find. It’s not, thanks to Every Man Jack. Spreading a tiny amount across your wet face results in some low-foam action that makes skin more visible, which is a huge benefit when navigating a razor across delicate body parts. The formula is ideal for sensitive skin, using olive oil, chamomile and aloe to keep it hydrated and soothed. Also, the 1.05-ounce size is convenient for on-the-go shaving and takes up very little space in any dopp kit. For only $2, you can’t beat it.

16. Marlowe Shave Cream

BEST FOR SKIN REPAIR

Cuts and nicks are all part of the shaving experience, but if you’re someone whose blemishes don’t heal so quickly, it’s time to reconsider the shaving cream you’re using. Marlowe employs its own proprietary M Blend, which has revitalizing extracts (e.g. green tea, deep-sea algae, willow bark) to improve your skin’s appearance and health. Shea butter and coconut oil help to form a barrier on the shaving surface and prep the blades for a close, smooth shave, while feeding skin with anti-inflammatory and healing nutrients. These same ingredients also make it a worthy unisex shaving cream, though its suave scent may appeal more to men.

17. The Art of Shaving Unscented Shaving Cream

BEST UNSCENTED

This no-frills, premium shave cream from The Art of Shaving takes inspiration from old school products, only it provides a more reliable shave without leaving behind an unflattering scent on your skin. It does a superb job of moistening thick hairs, creating a rich and foamy lather when whipped up to improve razor glide. Many of the company’s shaving products are made with sensitive skin in mind, including this one. Plus, TAOS takes the initiative to update its ingredients list as frequently as possible, placing emphasis on the shaver’s health over all other factors. A jar of this goes a long way.

Also Consider: Dollar Shave Club Shave Butter

HONORABLE MENTION

If you haven’t ever tried Dollar Shave Club, what the hell are you waiting for? The first round is only $5 for an entire shave kit— it’s at least something you need to try out. With a brand new look for 2022 and a new lower price, there’s never been a better time than now to try out DSC’s products, which include this moisturizing Shave Butter. So if you’re ready to try something besides shaving cream, then this skin-friendly formula is a great alternative for your dopp kit.

This stuff is a whole different ballpark when it comes to stellar shaving creams. This stuff is practically free the first time around and allows for some of the smoothest shaves we’ve ever experienced. While the tube itself is relatively small, a little goes a long way, so you’ll have this shaving cream way longer than it’ll take for you to get your next box.

The Absolute Best Razors for Every Type of Guy